Why Christians Should Shut Up

In his A Brief Reader on the Virtues of the Human Heart, Josef Pieper wrote on the virtue of silence in this way
Since reason is nothing else than the power to understand reality, then all reasonable, sensible, sound, clear and heart-stirring talk stems from listening silence. Thus all discourse requires a foundation in the motherly depth of silence. Otherwise speech is sourceless: it turns into chatter, noise and deception…Talk…sets its roots downward into the nourishing soil of silence.
Pieper contrasts this with what he calls “a particular form of nonsilence” that
…has always been regarded as a kin of despair: talkativeness, babble, the unquenchable frenzy of idle talk…talk of this kind, which one encounters truly everywhere in the workplace and marketplace as a constant temptation…appears to be connected with hopelessness.
Such observations are still pertinent in a world where speech has shifted to the world of social media, which drives its users to collapse into a single calculus, the quality of communications and the quantity of words. We desparately jam the airways and occupy zetabytes of bandwidth in the clamour to be heard and understood. In such a frenzy, one should not be surprised then that communications very soon gives way to aggression, as the torrents of abuse that crowd the com-boxes of blogs, forums and YouTube videos demonstrate.
This is not an accident of the online format. As Graham Ward reminds us in his Cities of God, the internet is unique in its institutionalisation of aggressive desire. Any communication that remains in its vortex of anonymity, Ward argues, mutates into what Augustine calls the “lust for domination”.
If this is the case, then the Christian engagement to online communications (for such communications, for better or worse, remain a necessary task of discipleship) must involve more than just getting “good content” up. However good the content, that response alone risks getting sucked into the “nonsilence” that Pieper identified. A complete response involves avenues outside the online format, as well in within.
Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, in his 46th World Communications Day message, provided in immensely helpful contribution in his reiteration of the importance of silence in communication, not only as a means of deepening understanding communication, but also in creating spaces of peace in what might otherwise be a maelstrom of words
In silence, we are better able to listen to and understand ourselves; ideas come to birth and acquire depth; we understand with greater clarity what it is we want to say and what we expect from others; and we choose how to express ourselves. By remaining silent we allow the other person to speak, to express him or herself; and we avoid being tied simply to our own words and ideas without them being adequately tested. In this way, space is created for mutual listening, and deeper human relationships become possible.
If God speaks to us even in silence, we in turn discover in silence the possibility of speaking with God and about God. We need that silence which becomes contemplation, which introduces us into God’s silence and brings us to the point where the Word, the redeeming Word, is born

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Why Christians Should Shut Up

  1. I like the point about the way internet communication (as we often encounter it) is correlated with the 'lust for domination'. I'm not so sure about Ward's connection between “any communication that remains in the vortex of anonymity” and that same lust for domination, though. Anonymous communication seems to have an ecclesial and sacramental side to it as well. E.g. the priest who celebrates the Tridentine Mass. That being said, if such a case is really a case of anonymous communication it seems to be good only insofar as it involves a kind of silence as well…

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s